Tuesday, 11 June 2019

Classification of Institutions Under the Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996

The Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996 (the Act) defined all institutions established under its provisions as private higher educational institutions.

The Private Higher Educational Institutions (Amendment) Act 2017 introduced definitions for colleges and foreign branch campuses that are established under the Act. With the new definitions added by the Amendment Act, PHEIs now fall into six categories, namely; colleges, universities, university colleges, branch campuses of private universities and private university colleges, branch campuses of foreign universities and branch colleges.

The Amendment Act defines ‘College’ as a private higher educational institution without the status of a University, University or University College or a foreign branch campus.’
The ‘Foreign branch campus’ is defined as ‘a branch of a foreign University or University College that is established’ under the Act. The Act makes no further reference to a foreign branch campus in any of its provisions. Neither are there any provisions in the Act to determine what would constitute a branch campus of a foreign university or for the need by the parent university to acknowledge its relationship with the foreign branch campus. The Act does not stipulate criteria to qualify as a foreign branch campus, except to include foreign branch campus in the general definition of a private higher educational institution as shown in the last paragraph. There are also no express provisions in the Act that classify the foreign branch campus as a university. The Act defines University and University College as a private higher educational institution conferred with the status of a University or University. This is probably only an oversight. In any case, the university status of the foreign branch campus may be implied from the definition of College and the provisions of section 21 and section 44 of the Act. The latter section, as amended, reads as follows;
“Award of degree
44. No private higher educational institution may award a degree unless such private higher educational institution is a University or a University College or a foreign branch campus.”(Emphasis added).
The Amendment Act redefines ‘University and University College’ as ‘a private higher educational institution conferred with the status of a University or University College under s. 21’ of the Act. The definition before the amendment was, ‘“University” and “University College” mean a private higher educational institution conferred with the status of a University or University College under section 21, and include such private higher educational institution which is affiliated to a University or University College whether within or outside Malaysia, conferred with the status of a University or a University College.’ It is doubtful if s. 21 of the Act confers the status of university on any institution. A literal interpretation of the section only requires ‘prior approval of the Minister’ to be obtained for the establishment of a private higher educational institution with the status of a university, which is the same requirement for the establishment of any private higher educational institution under s. 6 of the Act. The Act does not empower the Minister to confer any status on the institutions whose establishment he approves. The Minister’s role in the establishment of any type of private higher educational institution is limited to approving the establishment and no more. The decision to establish a university or college or any other institution recognised by the Act is on the applicant.
All private higher educational institutions, whether university or college, fall within the general definition of a private higher educational institution under the Act and they are all, without exception, subject to all the provisions of the Act. (s. 23 of the Act).
‘Private higher educational institution’ is now redefined as ‘. . .  an organization or educational institution, including a University or a University College or a foreign branch campus or College’, approved and registered under this Act, which is not established or maintained by the Government.’
With one exception, the Act is the only regulatory instrument that permits the establishment of a higher educational institution that is not established and maintained by the government. The exception, is an institution established under s. 5A (2) of the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 (UUCA). Under that subsection, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong may, on the advice of the Minister, by order published in the Gazette, authorize the establishment of any higher educational institution having the status of a University, whatever its name or style, if he is satisfied that it is expedient in the national interest that such higher educational institution should be established. There is an important difference in the process and status of a university that is created under s. 5A (2) and universities that are created under the provisions of s. 6, which is how all public universities are created under the UUCA.
Under s. 6(1) of the UUCA, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong may, on the advice of the Minister, by order published in the Gazette, authorize the establishment of any higher educational institution having the status of a University, whatever its name or style, if he is satisfied that it is expedient in the national interest that such higher educational institution should be established.
Section 7(1) of the same Act then provides that ‘upon the coming into force of the Incorporation Order made under section 6, a higher educational institution having the status of a University, with the name and style assigned to it by the Order, shall be deemed to have been established, and by which name the Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor and the members for the time being of the Board and the Senate shall be deemed to have been constituted a body corporate’ with all the attendant powers of a corporation. The establishment of the university and the incorporation of the university are contemporaneous processes under the UUCA.
In the case of universities created under s. 5A (2) of the UUCA, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong only ‘authorizes the establishment of any higher educational institution having the status of a University, whatever its name or style’. The authorization does not incorporate the university, only that it may be established. This by itself would not have prevented the university established under 5A (2) from being established and maintained by the Government. However, s. 5A (1) expressly declares that the provisions of UUCA shall not apply to any higher educational institution with the status of a University which is authorized to be established under subsection 5A (2). The result of this provision is that a university established under 5A (2) is excluded from those provisions of the Act dealing with Grants in Aid from the Parliament and other privileges in respect of establishing a campus or acquiring land for the purposes of the university.  What is unusual in all this is that the university created under s. 5A (2) is placed in a limbo between the UUCA and the Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996 because neither Act applies to it.
Apart from the unusual case of the university formed under 5A (2), the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 is a template legislation for the establishment of public universities and university colleges. But not all government-funded universities are established under the UUCA. Government funded universities are also established through special Acts of Parliament, as is the case with the University Institute Technology Mara (UiTM).
Other than universities and university colleges, public-funded higher education institutions include polytechnics, community colleges, teacher training institutes and scores of colleges.

Types of  Institutions Registered under the Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996

The Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996 (the Act) embraces all levels and types of  higher educational institutions from colleges to universities, irrespective of size and regardless of their mode of delivery, whether by it is by traditional, face to face methods, online, or by distance education and includes universities established in this country as branches of foreign universities. 
Even professional bodies that offer courses leading to membership in those bodies are brought within the scope of the Act. The PHEI may be a provider of higher education or distance education either by itself or in affiliation, association or collaboration with another higher education or a professional body. The affiliation may be with an institution, whether local or foreign. The full statutory definition is reproduced to show the extensiveness of the definition. The complex definition was adopted to bring within the purview of the legislation all the different types of institutions that were in operation in the private sector when the Act was first passed in 1996. It also reveals the innovative evolution of the private sector of higher education.
The definition is as follows;

‘private higher educational institution’ means an organization or educational institution, including a University or a University College or a branch campus, approved and registered under this Act, which is not established or maintained by the Government—
(a)  providing higher education;
(b)  providing distance education; or
(i) a private higher educational institution approved and registered under this Act;
(ii) other higher educational institutions—
(aa) whether or not established under other written laws; or 
(bb) whether within or outside Malaysia;
(iii) a University or University College established under this Act;
(iv) a University or University College established under the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 [Act 30];
(v) other Universities or University Colleges—
(aa)                whether or not established under other written laws; or
(bb) whether within or outside Malaysia;
(vi) a branch campus; or
(vii) a professional body whether within or outside Malaysia leading to the award of    professional membership of such professional body;’

The regulatory provisions of the Act apply equally to all institutions established under its provisions regardless of the level of education provided or the mode of delivery adopted.  

Institutions in the private sector include both for profit and not for profit institutions. Ownership models range from pure business enterprises, some of which are listed on the Kuala Lumpur Stock Exchange (Bursa Malaysia) to Government Linked Companies, state governments, political parties, and philanthropic entities. A number of universities are established as ‘foreign branch campuses’ of foreign universities and carry the names of those foreign universities. These institutions are also established under the same regulations that apply to local institutions that are established under the Act. Apart from the private universities and university colleges, there are about 400 institutions registered under the Act, also described as private higher educational institutions that have no degree awarding powers. Most of these colleges offer only diploma or professional programs, but a few teach to undergraduate and postgraduate levels through arrangements with local and foreign universities.
The vast and varied landscape of the private sector of higher education as seen today is the result of the phenomenal growth of private colleges that took place over the last four decades. What is especially remarkable about that growth is that many of the larger private institutions that are in operation today, including some of the private universities are the offspring of individual-owned small institutions registered as tuition centres under the then prevailing law.  

Today, there are as many private tertiary/post-secondary institutions as there are public institutions. Private sector student enrolments match those in public institutions. The impetus for the growth of the private sector of higher education continues to lie in the profound demand in the population for higher education.

Friday, 7 June 2019

Reform of Education A Reason To Start Blogging Again

Have been away too long.

Maybe now is a good time now to start again with all the talk and plans to reform education in the country. The new government that came into power in May 2018 promised a reform of the education sector. One year down, the talk continues but there is very little to show by way action or any clear direction that will be taken. One, rather easy problem that has been a bugbear of the national education system is the recognition of the UEC examinations for admission to higher education. The qualification is a long-respected HE qualification recognized by almost all countries that have educational systems like ours, but the UEC is not recognized by local public universities. Recognition of this qualification whose legitimacy springs from the same source of law as other local qualifications should never have been an issue, but it has become a political issue gluing our feet to inaction.

Turning to other matters in higher education, there have been suggestions to harmonize the private and public sectors. Focus is on the two main legislation on higher education, the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 and the Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996. How this will be achieved and whether the differentiation will be maintained between the public and private sectors are some of the issues that will be covered here.

So, as with all journeys, I hope this is an auspicious time to start and that I will have the fortitude and stamina to continue.