Tuesday, 18 June 2019

Constitutions Now Prescribed for Private Higher Educational Institutions


The Private Higher Educational Institutions (Amendment) Act 2017 and the Private Higher Educational Institutions (Constitutions) Regulations 2017 introduce new laws and regulations on, inter alia, the institutional constitution of PHEIs. The new 2017 Regulations introduces a set of template or model constitutions whose terms are to be adopted by the institutions.

Act 555 has always required PHEIs to be managed strictly in accordance with the institutional constitution and the Act. Indeed, it is a requirement of the Act (s. 11) that at the time when an application is made for the establishment of a PHEI, the Minister must be ‘satisfied’ ‘there is established a proper system of governance of the private higher educational institution with a constitution that shall be approved by the Registrar General’. An approved constitution is a prerequisite for the Minister’s approval to establish a PHEI. Once established, the institution must be managed in accordance with the terms of the approved constitution (s.30).

Act 555 as it now stands only requires the constitution to be approved by the Registrar General. There are no provisions in the Act or in any Regulations issued under the Act that stipulate the provisions that are to be included in the constitution other than the implied requirement in s. 11 of the Act that the constitution incorporates ‘a proper system of governance of the PHEI’.

The MOE’s preoccupation with the institutional constitution can be traced back to August 2009. The Ministry (then the Ministry of Higher Education), held a workshop to draft standard constitutions for private universities and colleges. To the Ministry’s circular inviting participants to the workshop (JPT/GS(R) 3000-600 (14) dated 19 August 2009) was attached a copy of a constitution of a public university. Participants in the workshop included representatives from both sectors of higher education as well as officials from the Ministry of Higher Education. The discussions of August 2009 produced the first set of two draft template constitutions for private colleges and universities. These were circulated to all institutions in the private sector at the end of 2009. The templates were based on the model constitution in Schedule I of the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 with modifications ostensibly to fit the needs of PHEIs. The first versions circulated in 2010 were replaced with later versions in 2012 which are the current official ‘standard’ constitutions for private universities and colleges. Both versions were issued through circulars from the Ministry without any reinforcement through legislation or statutory regulations.

The 2017 amendments to s. 30 and the proposed issuance of new regulations on the constitutions appear to stem from doubts about the enforceability of the earlier circulars that issued the template constitutions. There are no provisions under the Act that empowers the minister to prescribe any provisions to be included in the institutional constitution. The Registrar’s powers, as noted earlier, are limited to approving the constitution, not determining what the constitution should contain. The Act is silent as to the provisions that have to be included in the constitution.

The lack of power is addressed through an amendment to the current s. 30. Section 10 of the Amendment Act replaces the current section with a new section that reads as follows;

“Constitution
30. (1) The constitution of a private higher educational institution shall contain provisions for such matters as may be prescribed. (emphasis added)
Subject to the provisions of this Act, every private higher educational institution shall be managed in strict accordance with its constitution.
The constitution shall not be amended without the prior approval of the Registrar General.
Any private higher educational institution which contravenes the provisions of this section shall be guilty of an offence.”

As mentioned earlier, the current s. 30 only provides that the ‘constitution shall not be amended without the prior approval of the Registrar General’. The amended section 30 requires the constitution of a PHEI ‘to contain provisions for such matters as may be prescribed.’
In May 2019, the MOE circulated two template constitutions to PHEIs for their feedback. The provisions in these constitutions are essentially the same provisions that were found in the documents circulated to PHEIs in 2012. The structure and provisions in the latest documents are still based on the model constitution of the University and University Colleges Act 1971 with modifications to fit PHEIs.

The governance system embedded in the proposed constitutions presents several problems. The most serious is that they are drafted on the erroneous assumption (it is submitted), that the private higher educational institution established under the Act is an entity capable of acting on its own. Based on this assumption, the draft constitutions ignore the role and position of the company that established the institution and instead directs all its provisions at the PHEI as if it can be separated from the company and be treated separately and exclusively. This is misconceived. Unlike the university established under the UUCA, the private higher educational institution is not an incorporated body with the attributes of a legal person. It must rely on the company to animate it, to give it the capacity to act. The institution emanates from the company and only the company can act on its behalf. The new s. 75A added by the 2017 amendments recognizes the PHEI’s dependence on the company. Any attempt to prescribe a constitution for the management of private universities and colleges must direct the requirements at the company establishing those institutions and require the company to apply the prescribed constitution in managing the institution it created. The PHEI is, in reality, a company carrying on the business of a university or college. Critical to that definition is the company’s status as an incorporated entity with all the attributes of a legal person. Further, since the institution exists under the aegis of the company, one must look to the locus of control in the company to carry out the activities of the PHEI, which is the Board of Directors of the company. Section 211(1) of the Companies Act 2016 provides that ‘the business and affairs of the company shall be managed by, or under the direction of the Board'. It is questionable therefore if a document such as the draft constitution which is issued through delegated powers of another enactment can transfer the management powers of a registered company to another body such as the BOG created under the draft constitution. Any attempt by the draft constitutions to place management functions on a Board of Governors will not be effective in law unless the BOG is created by the company and managed through its board of directors or under the direction of the board of directors. The BOG cannot usurp the powers of the board of directors of the company. For this reason alone, the regulations may not be enforceable under existing laws on the validity of such regulations.

Apart from issues concerning the legality of the provisions in the two constitutions, the bicameral governance system that is prescribed in them is unwieldy, bureaucratic and inefficient as a management structure and is not the only model available to PHEIS. The ‘prescribed’ constitutions with a single governance model may also not fit the vastly different ownership models that are found in the population of PHEIs.

Friday, 14 June 2019

Acceptance of Additional Languages in Higher Education – A Positive Turn to Multilingualism


Private higher educational institutions (PHEIs) in the country may soon be able to deliver their courses in more than one language with the approval of the Ministry of Education (MOE). This new policy is stated in a recent MOE circular that was sent to PHEIs asking them for their comments on a proposed set of standards and criteria that would be applied for the approval of additional languages.

The MOE’s move on additional language is about the most progressive step that it has taken since the inception of the Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996. The Act enforced the official National Language policy but allowed institutions established under the Act to conduct their courses in a language other than the national language. The original provision in 1996 allowed the Minister to approve the teaching of a course of study in English or teach Islamic religion in Arabic. In 2009, the law was changed to allow private institutions to conduct a course of study in any other language it deems appropriate subject to the approval of the Minister. The statutory concession on the National Language requirement imposed on institutions an obligation to teach the National Language as a compulsory language to students who followed a course of study or a substantial part of a course of study in a language other than the National Language.

 The politics of language in the country never allowed our rich diversity in language and culture to surface as valuable assets in our educational settings. Language use in education, instead of being decided by teachers and educationists, is always determined by politicians and sometimes by the courts. The highest court in the land did not have the mettle to separate language use in higher education from the politics of education - I refer to the Merdeka University case that was heard in 1981. It actually left higher education in disarray, forcing public universities to surreptitiously use English. The language problem continues to beset education and retard development at all levels. Language is one of the factors that divide the educational sector.

There is therefore much to rejoice in the new policy on the use of a second or additional language to deliver courses in private higher educational institutions. The decision creates the space to develop a multilingual system of higher education that will also help to build and maintain local cultures and languages. More than that, being situated under the great shade of China and Mandarin and amidst other great Asian languages, the new policy will create opportunities for the private sector to explore new ways to link with higher educational demands in the region.

The Ministry of Education must be complimented for this bold new move.

Tuesday, 11 June 2019

Classification of Institutions Under the Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996

The Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996 (the Act) defined all institutions established under its provisions as private higher educational institutions.

The Private Higher Educational Institutions (Amendment) Act 2017 introduced definitions for colleges and foreign branch campuses that are established under the Act. With the new definitions added by the Amendment Act, PHEIs now fall into six categories, namely; colleges, universities, university colleges, branch campuses of private universities and private university colleges, branch campuses of foreign universities and branch colleges.

The Amendment Act defines ‘College’ as a private higher educational institution without the status of a University, University or University College or a foreign branch campus.’
The ‘Foreign branch campus’ is defined as ‘a branch of a foreign University or University College that is established’ under the Act. The Act makes no further reference to a foreign branch campus in any of its provisions. Neither are there any provisions in the Act to determine what would constitute a branch campus of a foreign university or for the need by the parent university to acknowledge its relationship with the foreign branch campus. The Act does not stipulate criteria to qualify as a foreign branch campus, except to include foreign branch campus in the general definition of a private higher educational institution as shown in the last paragraph. There are also no express provisions in the Act that classify the foreign branch campus as a university. The Act defines University and University College as a private higher educational institution conferred with the status of a University or University. This is probably only an oversight. In any case, the university status of the foreign branch campus may be implied from the definition of College and the provisions of section 21 and section 44 of the Act. The latter section, as amended, reads as follows;
“Award of degree
44. No private higher educational institution may award a degree unless such private higher educational institution is a University or a University College or a foreign branch campus.”(Emphasis added).
The Amendment Act redefines ‘University and University College’ as ‘a private higher educational institution conferred with the status of a University or University College under s. 21’ of the Act. The definition before the amendment was, ‘“University” and “University College” mean a private higher educational institution conferred with the status of a University or University College under section 21, and include such private higher educational institution which is affiliated to a University or University College whether within or outside Malaysia, conferred with the status of a University or a University College.’ It is doubtful if s. 21 of the Act confers the status of university on any institution. A literal interpretation of the section only requires ‘prior approval of the Minister’ to be obtained for the establishment of a private higher educational institution with the status of a university, which is the same requirement for the establishment of any private higher educational institution under s. 6 of the Act. The Act does not empower the Minister to confer any status on the institutions whose establishment he approves. The Minister’s role in the establishment of any type of private higher educational institution is limited to approving the establishment and no more. The decision to establish a university or college or any other institution recognised by the Act is on the applicant.
All private higher educational institutions, whether university or college, fall within the general definition of a private higher educational institution under the Act and they are all, without exception, subject to all the provisions of the Act. (s. 23 of the Act).
‘Private higher educational institution’ is now redefined as ‘. . .  an organization or educational institution, including a University or a University College or a foreign branch campus or College’, approved and registered under this Act, which is not established or maintained by the Government.’
With one exception, the Act is the only regulatory instrument that permits the establishment of a higher educational institution that is not established and maintained by the government. The exception, is an institution established under s. 5A (2) of the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 (UUCA). Under that subsection, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong may, on the advice of the Minister, by order published in the Gazette, authorize the establishment of any higher educational institution having the status of a University, whatever its name or style, if he is satisfied that it is expedient in the national interest that such higher educational institution should be established. There is an important difference in the process and status of a university that is created under s. 5A (2) and universities that are created under the provisions of s. 6, which is how all public universities are created under the UUCA.
Under s. 6(1) of the UUCA, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong may, on the advice of the Minister, by order published in the Gazette, authorize the establishment of any higher educational institution having the status of a University, whatever its name or style, if he is satisfied that it is expedient in the national interest that such higher educational institution should be established.
Section 7(1) of the same Act then provides that ‘upon the coming into force of the Incorporation Order made under section 6, a higher educational institution having the status of a University, with the name and style assigned to it by the Order, shall be deemed to have been established, and by which name the Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor and the members for the time being of the Board and the Senate shall be deemed to have been constituted a body corporate’ with all the attendant powers of a corporation. The establishment of the university and the incorporation of the university are contemporaneous processes under the UUCA.
In the case of universities created under s. 5A (2) of the UUCA, the Yang di-Pertuan Agong only ‘authorizes the establishment of any higher educational institution having the status of a University, whatever its name or style’. The authorization does not incorporate the university, only that it may be established. This by itself would not have prevented the university established under 5A (2) from being established and maintained by the Government. However, s. 5A (1) expressly declares that the provisions of UUCA shall not apply to any higher educational institution with the status of a University which is authorized to be established under subsection 5A (2). The result of this provision is that a university established under 5A (2) is excluded from those provisions of the Act dealing with Grants in Aid from the Parliament and other privileges in respect of establishing a campus or acquiring land for the purposes of the university.  What is unusual in all this is that the university created under s. 5A (2) is placed in a limbo between the UUCA and the Private Higher Educational Institutions Act 1996 because neither Act applies to it.
Apart from the unusual case of the university formed under 5A (2), the Universities and University Colleges Act 1971 is a template legislation for the establishment of public universities and university colleges. But not all government-funded universities are established under the UUCA. Government funded universities are also established through special Acts of Parliament, as is the case with the University Institute Technology Mara (UiTM).
Other than universities and university colleges, public-funded higher education institutions include polytechnics, community colleges, teacher training institutes and scores of colleges.